All indications are Jesus Christ was never born on December 25th

by OCP on December 27, 2012

in Featured News, News


Even as Christians celebrate the festive season, no one knows the exact time or place or month or year when Jesus of Nazareth was born.

This is even more true when one considers that the same Christians do celebrate Christmas on different occasions, with Orthodox observing it in January.

In any case, the calendar that is followed in the West was only created in the 6th Century, long after Jesus of Nazareth was born. Hence, in calculating back the years, the holy monk made a mistake by neither having a zero year between the years 1 BC and 1 AD.

Moreover if Jesus was born during the reign of Herod the Great, who only died in 5BC as Mathew’s gospel tells us, then there is no way Jesus could have been born after that, say in 1AD.

And to complicate matters, James the younger brother of the Lord was the one born in the year 1AD and not Jesus. No wonder for a long time, some Christians always referred to James rather than Jesus as the Lord.


St Luke story

I read with keen interest several letters by Rev Martin Olando and, while supporting his sentiments on the debate whether December 25 is the exact day Jesus was born, it would appear that the day allocated for Christmas is not exactly the day when the holy Christ was born.

Writing about the time of Jesus’ birth, the Bible says: “And there were shepherds in the same country (Judea) abiding in the field, and keeping watch at night over the flocks” (Luke 2: 7, 8).

Commenting on this statement of Luke, Bishop Barns in his book, Rise of Christianity on page 79 says: “There is moreover, no authority for the belief that December was the actual birthday of Jesus.

If we can give any credence to St Luke’s birth-story of the shepherds keeping watch by night in the fields near Bethlehem, the birth of Jesus did not take place in winter, when the night temperature is so low in the hill country of Judea that snow is not uncommon.

How then in the light of historical research into the origin of Christianity and Luke’s statement did the belief ever come to be entertained by Christians that Jesus was born in December? It seems very surprising winter and not summer was considered?

The incident referred to in Luke very probably took place in the month of August or September when fresh dates are found on palm-trees in Judea.




{ 0 comments… add one now }

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:

  • Buy the new book from the house of OCP:

    The Orthodox Dilemma

    Paperback – April 16, 2016
    by George Alexander

    The Orthodox Dilemma consists of personal reflections on global Pan-Orthodox Christian Unity. The work focuses on the need for establishing sacramental communion between the Eastern, Oriental and other families of Orthodox Churches. The author calls to create a common conciliar platform for Orthodox Churches and to establish dialogues between Eastern, Oriental, Old Believes, Old Calendar, Non-canonical, Unrecognized and New Generation Orthodox Churches.The major aim of the work is to provide different and unique aspects of Pan-Orthodox Christian Unity.The book also sheds light on problems, challenges and scope of inter-orthodox dialogue. This may be the first book of its kind to call for the creation of a global platform for all Orthodox Christians.The book tries to provide unique aspects of Orthodox Christianity.The work is a combination of personal thoughts of the author, history, contemporary Orthodoxy, dialogue and Pan-Orthodox Christian approach.

    Buy now: